Although it may seem unlikely, even extraordinary, it happened that in 1785 at 3:32 pm on August 12th while on his daily walk Immanuel Kant encountered a copy of Flaubert’s novel Madame Bovary lying on the sidewalk directly in his path. Kant was famous for setting out to walk at precisely the same time each day. His neighbors said that they could set their clocks by observing the time at which he passed their houses. One could conjecture Kant’s incredible precision in passing through the same space at exactly the same time repeatedly may have accounted in some way for an object from the future falling directly into his path. For indeed, the copy of Madame Bovary that Kant picked up was in fact dropped by a university student mirroring Kant’s path on August 12, 2013 at precisely 3:32 pm. His name was Johannes Friedenberg. He disliked the book and was glad to be rid of it when it mysteriously disappeared. During the evening of August 12th, 1785 Kant sat in his favorite chair and read the time-traveled copy of Madame Bovary.
During the year before this occurrence, 1784, Kant had thought a great deal about historical progress. In his writings he had expressed hope that with the passage of time the society he lived in would become more mature, more enlightened.
In an essay that year - Answer to the Question: "What is Enlightenment?" he wrote:
As history progressed “man's (natural) inclination and vocation to think freely (would) influence(s) the principles of governments, which find that they can themselves profit by treating man, who is more than a machine, in a manner appropriate to his dignity.”
As always, Kant was interested in finding Universal principles. Progress, he thought, was an attribute of Nature itself. In “Idea for a Universal History from a Cosmopolitan Point of View” Kant expressed his optimism about the future as follows:
FIRST THESIS
All natural capacities of a creature are destined to evolve completely to their natural end.
SECOND THESIS
SECOND THESIS
In man (as the only rational creature on earth) those natural capacities which are directed to the use of his reason are to be fully developed only in the race, not in the individual.
EIGHTH THESIS
The history of mankind can be seen, in the large, as the realization of Nature’s secret plan to bring forth a perfectly constituted state as the only condition in which the capacities of mankind can be fully developed, and also bring forth that external relation among states which is perfectly adequate to this end.
As he read Madame Bovary, Kant tested each thesis against the development of events in the novel.
Flaubert presents his characters in a specific time and place that exists decades ahead of Kant’s reading. They use inventions and act within the manners of their period that are different from Kant’s time but obviously a natural evolution from his period, thus supporting Thesis One.
Flaubert’s intention was to portray his characters realistically, ruthlessly. His goal was to write his cast of characters into full existence by describing them in the clearest, most resonant images possible. Kant was amazed by the writer’s craft but concluded that none of Flaubert’s characters in any way have their author’s sympathy. Flaubert had left any feelings of pity, compassion, or disgust to his readers discretion. This disturbed Kant he, like young Johannes centuries later, greatly disliked the book. He frankly wished that he had never encountered any of these people. However, the book was, without question, supporting evidence for Thesis Two.
On the morning of August 13th, at 1:32 am, Immanuel Kant was awakened from his sleep either by a cramp in his foot or by a mildly unpleasant dream. It began with the scratching of his pen as he wrote Thesis Eight slowly word-by-word, and then images of each of Flaubert’s country citizens flashed briefly before him. How could these people be anything but a barrier to Nature’s goal? They seem to be committed to ignoring the capacity for reason with which Nature had endowed them! Unpleasant as these French folk may be, Kant remained committed to Thesis Eight, remembering that he had written as proof of the thesis:
“The only question is: Does Nature reveal anything of a path to this end? And I say: She reveals something, but very little. This great revolution seems to require so long for its completion...”
Comforted by his thoughts, Kant brewed a cup of camomile tea for himself, massaged his aching foot, rinsed his cup, put it on the shelf and went back to bed.
Kant,"What is Enlightenment?"(1784)
Kant, Idea for a Universal History (1784)
Flaubert, Madame Bovary (1856)
No comments:
Post a Comment